HOME
Business Organizations
last update 23 Aug 02

 
MATERIA
 
CONEXUS
 
DIALECTICA
 
SYLLABUS

Previous Outline

 

Next Outline

 

 
CLASS NOTES

 

 
Outline
  • Internal affairs doctrine 
    • Internal affairs:  shareholder / management relations 
    • incoropation-based private ordering:  parties choose governing law 
    • reasons for doctrine
  • Foreign corporations 
    • doing business in state other than state of incorporation 
    • nature of state regulation 
    • constitutional protections 
  • Validity of state antitakeover regulation:  CTS Corp v. Dynamics Corp of America 
    • history and nature of antitaover laws 
    • Supremacy Clause:  consistency with federal WIlliams Act  
    • Commerce Clause: free commerce in corporate shares 
      • non-discrinatory 
      • inconsistent regulation 
      • hinder commercial transactions
    • limiting effect of market in corporate charters 

WHY DID THE CHICKEN CROSS THE ROAD?
  • Albert Camus: It doesn't matter; the chicken's actions have no meaning except to him. 
  • Aristotle: To actualize its potential. 
  • Confucius: Chicken who first look both way, lives to see another day. 
  • Epictetus: To enjoy the great festival of life with other hens. 
  • Epicurus: For fun. 
  • Eric Hoffer: To free itself from the tyranny of freedom by becoming a member of the flock. 
  • Henry David Thoreau: To live deliberately ... and suck all the marrow out of life. 
  • David Hume: Out of custom and habit. 
  • Immanuel Kant: The chicken, being an autonomous being, chose to cross the road of his own free will. 
  • Jacques Derrida: Any number of contending discourses may be discovered within the act of the chicken crossing the road, and each interpretation is equally valid as the authorial intent can never be discerned, because structuralism is DEAD, DAMMIT, DEAD! 
  • Karl Marx: It was a historical inevitability. 
  • Lao-tzu: The chicken does not cross the road yet reaches the other side. 
  • Ludwig Wittgenstein: The possibility of "crossing" was encoded into the objects "chicken" and "road," and circumstances came into being which caused the actualization of this potential occurrence. 
  • Machiavelli: The point is that the chicken crossed the road. Who cares why? The end of crossing the road justifies whatever motive there was. 
  • Murphy: The chicken will invariably cross the road at the worst possible time. 
  • Nietzsche: Because if you gaze too long across the Road, the Road gazes also across you. 
  • Plato: For the greater good. 
  • Ralph Waldo Emerson: It didn't cross the road; it transcended it. 
  • Zeno of Elea: To prove it could never reach the other side.
 
Problems

 A state legislator wants to restrict lobbying by public corporations operating in the state, by amending the Columbia business corporate act to permit shareholder to recover from directors   "any corporate funds used to secure defeat or pasge of pening or prosed legislation, unless authorized by 80% shareholder vote" 

Party A:  Argue that the provision is invalid under the US Constitution.

Part B:  Argue that the provision is a valid exercise of the powre to amend corporate law, reserved to the state legislature by law.

Readings