E 2558. Proposed by A. Torchinsky, Cornell University
Suppose that is a divergent series of positive terms, and let for . For which values of p does the series converge?
Solution by Elmer K. Hayashi. We prove a more general theorem from which we deduce that converges if and only if p>1.
Theorem. Let f(x), for x>0, be any nonnegative, continuous, monotonically decreasing, real-valued function. If is a divergent series of positive terms and if for , then
and
Proof: Intuitively we reason that if u=sn then du is analogous to sn - sn-1=an. Hence probably behaves somewhat like . Furthermore, if F(x) is any antiderivative of the continuous function f(x), then . Thus a natural series with which to compare is the telescoping series
(1) |
(2) |
From equation (2), it is apparent that the series (1) converges if and only if the integral, , is convergent. Now, by the mean value theorem,
for some ck between sk-1 and sk. Since f is monotonically decreasing, we have for ,
and
Using the Comparison test, we arrive at the conclusion of the theorem.
If we take , we conclude that converges for p > 1 and diverges for . In general, it is not true that if is diverent, then is also divergent. For example, if , a1 = s1 = 1 + e and an = sn-1 exp (2n-1) for n > 1, then . The series is divergent, by our theorem, since is divergent. However behaves like and therefore is convergent. However, in the special case , it is true that does diverge.
It suffices to prove diverges since for all sufficiently large n if as and . By the comparison test, the divergence of would then imply the divergence of for all . There are two cases to consider. Either for all sufficiently large n or otherwise there exist infinitely many n such that an > sn-1. In the former case, we have for all sufficiently large n
But we know is divergent, and hence, by the comparison test, is also divergent. In the second case, we have for infinitely many n
Thus and is divergent in this case, too. This completes our proof.
Elmer K. Hayashi Department of Mathematics Wake Forest University Winston-Salem, N. C. 27109